|
MY QUESTIONS ABOUT ISLAM
(written by a Muslim who has decided
to leave Islam)
Being born in a Muslim family, I am
raising some questions about Islam and inviting
all Muslims or non to answer me, if they
can, but in calm way like a gentleman.
1. There must only be 'Defense Right' rule
except 'JEHAD' for Muslims. No religion including
Islam has right to start war against any country
/ society / people or community in the name
of religion, GOD or JEHAD. Life of a human
being belongs to any religion or land is much
better and precious than a religion, faith
or belief.
2. There is a common and blasted conflict
between Israel and Muslim world upon 'so-called'
'FORCED OCCUPATION' of Jewish on Arabs territories.
Let me ask Muslims what they did in Spain for
800 years. Didn't they occupy their land? And
what Muslims did in India, India was a biggest
country with great traditions and cultures,
didn't they also occupy it by force? And finally
they obtained a piece of land from heart of
India in the name of religion and 'Allah'.
They named it 'Pakistan'. Although they could
easily breath together among other nations
with peace, dignity and 'free to act their
favorite religion, Islam' in a United India
like Singapore and many other countries but
they preferred ALLAH & ISLAM on humanity.
Occupying Spain and India by Muslims is justification
but same act is wrong for Israel. What a non-sense.
By the way, to the best of my knowledge Jewish
purchased the land from Arabs and then announced
for an independent state.
3. Why can't I express my views freely in
Pakistan or any other Islamic country, as I
did in Germany and Japan? Why can't I change
my religion? Why can't I exchange or share
my ideas liberally? Isn't it a clear assault
of my personal rights or sovereignty? In an
Islamic country, especially in Pakistan, at
peak deep sleeping time suddenly you hear a
loud screaming voice at 5 AM daily. You awake
up. Babies start crying, insomnia patients
become upset. Well! It is all right for you
but wrong for me if I even try to politely
explain that Azan (loud call for prayer) should
be announced only in single voice for whole
city in five-fixed time (if it is so necessary).
For this purpose a loudspeaker network system
can easily be established in every city on
very nominal expenses.
4. Nowadays life became much miserable and
people have to struggle from day to night to
earn their livelihoods. How is it possible
for a person to pray 5 times in a day? (One
time prayer takes ½ hour average time).
Cannot you, please, limit prayer times from
5 to 2 by IJTIHAD (mutual consultation, as
per Quran)?
5. Why veil is obligatory for a woman only?
Why men does not follow it. Most 'Ulma' (Islamic
Religious Leaders) say that if a man see a
woman's face unveiled, sexual thoughts move
in his mind which is 'Haram' (prohibited) in
Islam. Let me ask them that when a woman sees
a man's face or body exposed, doesn't she get
same sexual feelings in her mind like a male?
Isn't it 'Haram' for a her too? What is logic
behind it?
6. Why Islam doesn't let women to pray in
a Mosque? Why can't they lead prayer instead
of a male 'Imam'?. Why Islam classifies, discriminates
or considers, a female eyewitness as 'HALF'
against a male? Why Islam assigns "HALF
SHARE" to a female, against full to a
male from their parents' property? Why only
male has right to divorce, why can't a female
do so equally?
7. In Islam if you divorce your wife and again
want to marry her, it is obligatory that your
wife must marry some one else and new married
couple must make sexual intercourse, later
if her new husband divorce her upon his free
will, then you can marry with your former wife.
They call it 'Halala'. Isn't it shameful and
dishonorable act? I am quiet sure 'Ulmas' has
self generated this law for their own sexual
satisfaction, as they are always ready to offer
their humble services for these kind of noble
tasks.
8. Passing urine in standing position relaxed
a male but it is also prohibited in Islam.
May I ask mystery or hidden reimbursement behind
it?
9. If a 'Moulvi' (Islamic religious leader)
justifies suicide attacks against non-Muslims,
he must send his family members first for such
missions and then should preach other innocent
teenagers for this purpose. Do you agree? If
not, why?
10. Criticizers or condemners of West or USA,
should give up using any thing made of these
countries. They should not send their lovers
to these 'Kafar' (non Muslim) countries for
higher studies or any other purpose. They even
should not use Western inventions or discoveries.
I suggest them to quit traveling by trains;
aeroplanes or automobiles, just travel by ass
or horses and should spend their lives like
people of Stone Age. Whey don't you do so?
Why don't you try to understand that Qazi Hussain
Ahmed, President of a fundamentalist Islamic
Organization 'Jamaat-e-Islami Pakistan, always
speaks against West and USA, he is an extremist
and radical, but his own sons are getting higher
education in USA on your expenses.and donations.
When will you become realistic???????
11. Sexual satisfaction is natural gift for
human beings. It should be absolutely free.
There shouldn't be any restriction how and
to whom a person do sex. Only legal age limit
and mutual wish should be respected and law
should punish violators. If you diagree I would
like to draw your kind attention towards 'Harm',
(Women Palace) of Muslim Rulers. They kept
thousands of women in their palaces excluding
lot of wives at a time. Such additional women
were called as 'Kaneez' (comfort women). They
used them for their sexual satisfaction whenever
they wanted. Consequently lot of babies was
borne but they were not granted any part of
property or land from their father (or King).
Don't go so past, just look out Shaiks' 'Harm'
in present Middle East. They are packed with
such women and Shaiks are doing free sex with
them. Give me Quranic Versus' reference against
it as you always try to do so.
12. 'Qasas wa Diyat' or 'Khun Baha' "(compensation
to family or relative of a murdered person
by murderer)", is one of most dreadful,
horrible and shocking rule of Islam. I will
rule it 'License to Kill' for a wealthy person
because, if he murders some one and offer hand
some amount in return as a compensation to
the victim family or relatives, your sentence
will be vanished and you will be free in the
world (for more killing, perhaps), if your
offer is accepted, and off course in 99% cases
it is accepted. Suppose my wife is not happy
with me as well as my brothers and I am murdered
by some one. My murderer offers enough amounts
as compensation to my family. Of course! They
will happily accept it and murderer will be
free in society for more killing. Recently,
(April 2004), a Shaikh in Saudi Arabia murdered
a Pakistani but released from jail as well
as death sentence after paying lot of DINARS
(local currency) to the poor relatives and
family of victim, in the name of 'Qasas wa
Diyat' or 'Khun Baha'. What a pity! Life is
not so cheap. No one has right to offer money
as substitution of life. Whole constitution
of a society is demolished in existence of
this rule and so is going on in all Islamic
countries. Let me give example of my own country,
Pakistan. Since 1947, time of its independence,
no rich person has been hanged except two.
One was Mr. Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto who was hanged
on political grounds or personal grudge of
a Dictator and another was Shaikh Amjad who
had murdered a Barrister in Karachi last year
for ransom. Relatives and family of both murdered
persons rejected compensation offer because
they were also rich. I admit that there is
some examples when poor families of a murdered
person also didn't accept compensation offer
and resisted but they were threatened and pressurized
until they had to bent over against wealth.
This dark rule should completely be eliminated
and only President of a country should have
right to forgive death sentence of a murderer
like other civilized countries of the world.
Do you agree?
I have many more to ask... but let me apologize
first to all, or any, who suffered in distress
or misery due to above questions or enquiries.
Please be pity on me before issuing any KILLING
'FATWAS' against me, as I believe that MY LIFE
IS MUCH PRECIOUS THAN ISLAM.
Haji
Back to main page
|
